When a trademark lacks inherent distinctiveness, it may still be eligible for registration on the Principal Register if the applicant can establish that it has acquired distinctiveness, also known as secondary meaning. The United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) evaluates whether a trademark has acquired distinctiveness based on various forms of evidence. For a detailed explanation of the three primary types of proof accepted by the USPTO, visit our page on Acquired Distinctiveness and Secondary Meaning.
In certain cases, a claim of distinctiveness may not apply to the entire mark but only to a specific portion. This type of claim is referred to as a Section 2(f) “in part” claim. Whether the claim applies to the entire mark or just a portion, the standards for proving trademark acquired distinctiveness remain the same. The applicant bears the responsibility of identifying the exact portion of the mark for which distinctiveness is being asserted. Importantly, this portion must create a distinct commercial impression separate from the remaining elements of the mark.
When to Claim Acquired Distinctiveness in Part
A claim of acquired distinctiveness in part is commonly made when a mark includes a descriptive element alongside an inherently distinctive element. The descriptive portion must independently create a commercial impression for the applicant to assert acquired distinctiveness.
For example, a trademark containing a geographically descriptive term alongside an inherently distinctive element may qualify for a Section 2(f) in part claim if the applicant can demonstrate that the geographic term has independently acquired distinctiveness. The USPTO provides the example of TEXAS GOLD for car-cleaning preparations. If the applicant can establish that consumers recognize “TEXAS” by itself as identifying the source of the goods, a Section 2(f) in part claim may be appropriate for that portion of the mark. However, the applicant must provide sufficient evidence of acquired distinctiveness, and the claimed portion must create a separate commercial impression from the remaining elements.
Similarly, if a mark includes a surname, a claim of secondary meaning trademark can be made for that surname if the applicant can prove that it has acquired distinctiveness. Suppose a jewelry company uses the mark GOLDMAN JEWELRY but has historically marketed its products under “GOLDMAN” alone. In such a case, a Section 2(f) in part claim would apply to “GOLDMAN,” while “jewelry” would require a disclaimer.
Examiner’s Role in Acquired Distinctiveness Claims
When a trademark application includes a descriptive term, the USPTO examining attorney may request a disclaimer of that term unless the applicant can prove acquired distinctiveness. If an applicant provides evidence of distinctiveness, but the examining attorney finds it insufficient, they may suggest that additional proof be submitted. An applicant may support a Section 2(f) claim through ownership of qualifying prior registrations, a verified statement establishing at least five years of substantially exclusive and continuous use in commerce, or other evidence demonstrating acquired distinctiveness. However, five years of use does not automatically establish secondary meaning. The USPTO may require additional evidence, particularly when the proposed trademark is highly descriptive of the goods or services. The examining attorney may also suggest a Section 2(f) claim, including a claim limited to a particular portion of the mark, when appropriate. Additional guidance is available in the Trademark Manual of Examining Procedure (TMEP) Sections 1212.02(f), 1212.02(g), and 1212.05.
Determining the Strength of an Acquired Distinctiveness Claim
The level of evidence needed to establish acquired distinctiveness varies depending on the descriptiveness of the mark and other case-specific factors. The more descriptive a mark is in relation to the goods or services, the greater the burden of proof. Additionally, if the applicant’s use of the mark is not exclusive, proving acquired distinctiveness becomes even more challenging. However, the standard does not require absolute exclusivity—only “substantially exclusive” use. This means that minor third-party uses, particularly those that are inconsequential or infringing, do not necessarily weaken the applicant’s claim to trademark acquired distinctiveness.
However, widespread third-party use of the mark can significantly undermine an applicant’s claim. The USPTO evaluates each case individually based on its unique facts, and numerous third-party users can diminish the distinctiveness of the mark in the eyes of the public.
The Importance of a Strong Trademark Strategy
For businesses seeking to secure their trademarks on the Principal Register, understanding the nuances of acquired distinctiveness is crucial. If a mark lacks inherent distinctiveness, it is essential to gather robust evidence proving that the public has come to associate the mark with the applicant’s goods or services. This evidence may include consumer surveys, sales figures, advertising expenditures, and longstanding, substantially exclusive use in commerce.
When a USPTO examining attorney issues an Office Action refusing registration because a proposed trademark lacks inherent distinctiveness, a Section 2(f) claim may provide a possible response strategy if the applicable requirements can be satisfied. However, the evidence must demonstrate that consumers recognize the mark as identifying a particular commercial source. Applicants facing these issues can learn more about the available legal arguments and response procedures in Cohn Legal’s Trademark Office Action Response Attorneys guide.
If you are unsure whether your trademark qualifies as inherently distinctive or whether you need to assert distinctiveness through prior registration, secondary meaning, or five years of exclusive use, we are here to help. Contact one of our best Trademark Lawyers for a free consultation regarding your trademark or other intellectual property concerns.

